Freeze Checkpoint Errors
-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Freeze Checkpoint Errors
I will have to set this project to NNW for the simple reason that nearly all my work units (especially since the last day or so) are getting Zero credit.
It all appears to be something with trying to create a checkpoint or freeze checkpoint that fails and then does not match with my wingmen, even though the work unit appears to be successful.
It does not seem to matter what Boinc Client is in use (though none so far appear to match my version 6.6.40).
Nor does it appear to be Intel / AMD related as I am not matching with the same model computer running same OS either.
It all appears to be something with trying to create a checkpoint or freeze checkpoint that fails and then does not match with my wingmen, even though the work unit appears to be successful.
It does not seem to matter what Boinc Client is in use (though none so far appear to match my version 6.6.40).
Nor does it appear to be Intel / AMD related as I am not matching with the same model computer running same OS either.
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
We have not yet solved this problem but it exclusively seems to occour on 32 bit Linux. Can you remove the freeze application? That, to my knowledge, should help. It would be helpful to solve the exact cause for this issue - that's why we are still in testing phase...
Michael.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Thanks for the reply Michael, I have stopped work units from 'cmsearch' and allowed all other work unit types, just have to wait for more work now to see how it goes.Michael H.W. Weber hat geschrieben:We have not yet solved this problem but it exclusively seems to occour on 32 bit Linux. Can you remove the freeze application? That, to my knowledge, should help. It would be helpful to solve the exact cause for this issue - that's why we are still in testing phase...
Michael.
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Is it correct that you have a 32 bit Linux box running?
In about an hour, new work should be available, but for CMSEACRH only. CMCALIBRATE work units will come into play on the weekend but this time, only Linux on a 64 bit basis will be fed with those WUs.
Michael.
In about an hour, new work should be available, but for CMSEACRH only. CMCALIBRATE work units will come into play on the weekend but this time, only Linux on a 64 bit basis will be fed with those WUs.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Yes I am using 32 bit Fedora 11 on an AMD Phenom II X4 955, also running Climate Prediction and QMC on that computer. At this stage I wont be converting this Linux machine to 64 bit so it looks like I will miss out on the new work units.Michael H.W. Weber hat geschrieben:Is it correct that you have a 32 bit Linux box running?
In about an hour, new work should be available, but for CMSEACRH only. CMCALIBRATE work units will come into play on the weekend but this time, only Linux on a 64 bit basis will be fed with those WUs.
Michael.
I will think about hooking up another computer I have with the same processor but running Windows XP Professional, also 32 bit, and see if that is any better.
Michael, thanks again,
Conan.
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
With that machine you should not experience such issues.Conan hat geschrieben:[I will think about hooking up another computer I have with the same processor but running Windows XP Professional, also 32 bit, and see if that is any better.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Thanks Michael, all working OK on my Windows machine.Michael H.W. Weber hat geschrieben:With that machine you should not experience such issues.Conan hat geschrieben:[I will think about hooking up another computer I have with the same processor but running Windows XP Professional, also 32 bit, and see if that is any better.Thanks for your patience.
Michael.
There is one annoying thing that RNA World work units do, that no other project does.
Each time a different WU type is sent to me my antivirus software (ZoneAlarm) keeps popping up a warning that the RNA WU is wanting to access the Interent or trusted zone (I haven't taken a lot of notice which one but sometimes both).
The warning stays there until I look at the computer (which could be many hours later).
What this does is keeps the WU active but not processing as it waits for a response and the time processing and time to go keep going up. So once I say yes the WU processes very quickly but it reports a Run Time of hours and a CPU time of minutes.
Only happens for the first of each different WU type, the following ones are all fine.
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Oh, that is indeed annoying but strange as well. Is it possible to exclude the RNA World directory from being analyzed by this security tool (I know nobody wants to unnecessarily reduce safety measures, though)? Maybe some guys from our team have another idea. We will check.
Michael.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
EdmundBlackadder
- Task-Killer

- Beiträge: 784
- Registriert: 20.02.2008 17:56
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
I think, FW and AV issues can only be answered with a fresh installation, knowing the system config. Sometimes misconfiguration may lead to unexpected behaviour. When I get a webcam, I might offer teamviewer/netviewer online help support. Bad idea? Like this, only better. 
Verschenke 2 Stück Lenovo T400 (Screen defekt) 4GB Laptops mit Dockingstation und 17" Monitor.
Ritschie hat geschrieben:Ich will ja nicht nur für Credits rechnen, sondern 'nen sinnvollen Beitrag leisten.
-
AMDave
- Taschenrechner

- Beiträge: 12
- Registriert: 05.08.2007 03:02
- Wohnort: Australien
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
negative on the 32-bit only
http://www.rnaworld.de/rnaworld/workuni ... uid=158911
Wu type cmcalibrate v0.20
11 error responses on that WU alone.
Host 711 is Ubuntu_9.10_AMD64
Multiple platforms exhibiting this failure type.
Lots of work now being done for no result while this failure is prevalent.
Deserves further examination I think - in the urgent+important quadrant.
http://www.rnaworld.de/rnaworld/workuni ... uid=158911
Wu type cmcalibrate v0.20
11 error responses on that WU alone.
Host 711 is Ubuntu_9.10_AMD64
Multiple platforms exhibiting this failure type.
Lots of work now being done for no result while this failure is prevalent.
Deserves further examination I think - in the urgent+important quadrant.

-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Hi Dave,AMDave hat geschrieben:negative on the 32-bit only
what exactly do you mean by this? These WUs get delivered to x64 machines under Linux, only.
Yes, we need to look into this one as well. My machine has failed on this one as well as I just saw.AMDave hat geschrieben:http://www.rnaworld.de/rnaworld/workuni ... uid=158911
Wu type cmcalibrate v0.20
11 error responses on that WU alone.
Host 711 is Ubuntu_9.10_AMD64
Multiple platforms exhibiting this failure type.
Lots of work now being done for no result while this failure is prevalent.
Deserves further examination I think - in the urgent+important quadrant.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
AMDave
- Taschenrechner

- Beiträge: 12
- Registriert: 05.08.2007 03:02
- Wohnort: Australien
Re: Freeze Checkpoint Errors
Clarification no problem...
The start of the thread did not specify which application was being discussed but 32-bit was mentioned.
I wanted to clarify that the same error is also evident with the 64-bit app.
Since 32-bit is acknowledged as having this error type then I conclude that it is affecting cmsearch results.
Since 64-bit cmcallibrate is also exhibiting this error type then I conclude that results for both apps are affected.
The error results show that both AMD and Intel are affected.
The error results show that different distributions of linux are affected.
The main similarity between the 32-bit and 64-bit clients is the wrapper code.
This is also independent of the CPU type (or so I believe).
The error messages show that the checkpoint file does not get instantiated.
The error messages also show that the call to "./freeze" fails.
The checkpoint number does not increment - showing that the checkpoint subroutine is not working properly.
Check-pointing is executed by the wrapper.
I hypothesize that there is likely an implementation error in the code of the checkpointing subroutine in the wrapper.
It should be fairly obvious (when someone is looking over the shoulder of the developer - as we all know thats the way it happens) because it presents as an error on both 32-bit and 64-bit linux, regardless of compiler options (ie architecture) or linux distributions: That is to say cross architecture, cross distro, cross platform errors tend to stand out by the nature of being ... well ... fundemental. It will just look wrong
>> user prods developer, developer prods tester, tester sighs deeply and dreams of better use-cases.
The start of the thread did not specify which application was being discussed but 32-bit was mentioned.
I wanted to clarify that the same error is also evident with the 64-bit app.
Since 32-bit is acknowledged as having this error type then I conclude that it is affecting cmsearch results.
Since 64-bit cmcallibrate is also exhibiting this error type then I conclude that results for both apps are affected.
The error results show that both AMD and Intel are affected.
The error results show that different distributions of linux are affected.
The main similarity between the 32-bit and 64-bit clients is the wrapper code.
This is also independent of the CPU type (or so I believe).
The error messages show that the checkpoint file does not get instantiated.
The error messages also show that the call to "./freeze" fails.
The checkpoint number does not increment - showing that the checkpoint subroutine is not working properly.
Check-pointing is executed by the wrapper.
I hypothesize that there is likely an implementation error in the code of the checkpointing subroutine in the wrapper.
It should be fairly obvious (when someone is looking over the shoulder of the developer - as we all know thats the way it happens) because it presents as an error on both 32-bit and 64-bit linux, regardless of compiler options (ie architecture) or linux distributions: That is to say cross architecture, cross distro, cross platform errors tend to stand out by the nature of being ... well ... fundemental. It will just look wrong
>> user prods developer, developer prods tester, tester sighs deeply and dreams of better use-cases.
