I was crunching an XXl task but aborted it when I noticed that the minimum quorum is 2 while the initial replication is 3. If the duration estimate is accurate the task would have taken over 1,000 hours to complete and at that point there would be a 33% chance the task would not be needed because the minimum quorum of 2 would have already been met. In other words over 1,000 hours of computing time would be a total waste. No, it is not enough to receive credit for a task that is not needed. The issue is that the CPU time is a precious resource and should not be wasted. The credits mean nothing.
Why do you have such a wasteful policy? Why not just an initial replication of 2 if the minimum quorum is 2?
If you need a quorum of 3 then make the quorum 3 although you have already proven you need only quorum of 2
I have detached from this project and will not reattach until you either provide a reasonable explanation for this apparently abusive policy or change it. If you cannot offer a reasonable explanation and refuse to change it then I will report your abusive policy on 20 other projects and ask David Anderson to remove this project from the list of projects displayed in the Add Project wizard. I will also find every wiki that mentions this project and I will join that wiki and add to the article to warn volunteers of the abuse they will suffer here.
initial replication 3, minimum quorum 2
-
Dagorath
- Fingerzähler

- Beiträge: 2
- Registriert: 03.02.2013 23:59
-
yoyo
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 8170
- Registriert: 17.12.2002 14:09
- Wohnort: Berlin
Re: initial replication 3, minimum quorum 2
Why you are so agressive?
A lot of projects have a initial replication greater than the quorum. I think even WCG has.
We are at the end of some big batches which needs completion. To get them complete I increased initial replication, what I do always at the end of a batch. The reason is, that some user just detach from the project without reporting, that the workunit which they downloaded they will not return. So it takes until the deadline (30, for some wus 60 days) until the server recognizes it and resents the result. Therefore the initial replication is 3 near the end of a batch.
yoyo
A lot of projects have a initial replication greater than the quorum. I think even WCG has.
We are at the end of some big batches which needs completion. To get them complete I increased initial replication, what I do always at the end of a batch. The reason is, that some user just detach from the project without reporting, that the workunit which they downloaded they will not return. So it takes until the deadline (30, for some wus 60 days) until the server recognizes it and resents the result. Therefore the initial replication is 3 near the end of a batch.
yoyo