Waiting for memory
-
Jax
- Fingerzähler

- Beiträge: 2
- Registriert: 12.03.2010 23:39
Waiting for memory
I know from the from news on the front page that some of the work units may require large amount of RAM. But I have a work unit (Task 1305845) that is sitting with "Waiting for memory" and not running even though there 12gb installed on the machine with 8.5gb free. I have 2 other cmsearch units running and combined they are using just under 2gb or memory. Any idea why this unit would not be running, there are no other free tasks available so it is just leaving an available core idle, I can't image it could possibly need more than that amount of memory.
-
Norman
- Klimawolke

- Beiträge: 2188
- Registriert: 20.03.2003 14:34
- Wohnort: Saarland
Re: Waiting for memory
I´ve also 12gb and by me some WU just stop the work also. RAM is free enough.
-
Ananas
- WU-Schieber

- Beiträge: 1184
- Registriert: 27.04.2008 18:37
- Wohnort: Nordlichter Köln
Re: Waiting for memory
Maybe the memory limits on your account :
Use at most xx% of memory when computer is in use
Use at most xx% of memory when computer is not in use
That's what all WUs together are allowed to use.
Another possible reason (I'm just guessing here) would be that BOINC uses a too short variable when summing up the WU RAM to a grand total, resulting in an overflow.
It is not a shortage for the workunit itself - if that would occur, it would crash. It is a BOINC issue.
Use at most xx% of memory when computer is in use
Use at most xx% of memory when computer is not in use
That's what all WUs together are allowed to use.
Another possible reason (I'm just guessing here) would be that BOINC uses a too short variable when summing up the WU RAM to a grand total, resulting in an overflow.
It is not a shortage for the workunit itself - if that would occur, it would crash. It is a BOINC issue.
vi BOINC/checkin_notes
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
-
Jax
- Fingerzähler

- Beiträge: 2
- Registriert: 12.03.2010 23:39
Re: Waiting for memory
Thank Ananas, that seems to have done it. Boinc was set to 50% max, when I kicked it up to 75% the unit started back up. Weird though that even at the old setting it would have still left 4gb of memory free to use and now that its running it only using about 600mb. But who knows, its running and that's all I care about! 
-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Re: Waiting for memory
Could it also have something to do with Virtual memory ?
I have noticed that physical memory is nowhere near used but a large amount of virtual memory is in use and that has been close to stopping my work units, but so far I have not seen the waiting for memory message.
I have 4 GB of RAM but also run a couple of other projects so rarely have all 4 cores trying to grab all available memory.
Windows has popped up a couple of times and said I was running out of Virtual memory and it was increasing the amount of memory available, very nice of it to do that, don't you think.
I have noticed up to 5.3 GB has been in use when I only have 4 GB of physical memory (being 32 bit I can use 3 GB physical).
Conan.
I have noticed that physical memory is nowhere near used but a large amount of virtual memory is in use and that has been close to stopping my work units, but so far I have not seen the waiting for memory message.
I have 4 GB of RAM but also run a couple of other projects so rarely have all 4 cores trying to grab all available memory.
Windows has popped up a couple of times and said I was running out of Virtual memory and it was increasing the amount of memory available, very nice of it to do that, don't you think.
I have noticed up to 5.3 GB has been in use when I only have 4 GB of physical memory (being 32 bit I can use 3 GB physical).
Conan.
-
Conan
- XBOX360-Installer

- Beiträge: 80
- Registriert: 11.02.2010 11:09
Re: Waiting for memory
I have just checked my settings and found that I have set "Use at most 90% page file" and "Use 90% memory when computer not in use" plus "Use at most 70% memory when computer is in use".
As this is my original settings from many moons ago, it probably explains why most of my work units have been able to complete even with just 4 GB physical RAM as they can use virtually all my system resources when I am not using it.
As this is my original settings from many moons ago, it probably explains why most of my work units have been able to complete even with just 4 GB physical RAM as they can use virtually all my system resources when I am not using it.
-
Ananas
- WU-Schieber

- Beiträge: 1184
- Registriert: 27.04.2008 18:37
- Wohnort: Nordlichter Köln
Re: Waiting for memory
You might be right, but that would be somehow weird, as it would mean that a machine with 4GB physical and 8GB swap would be allowed to use 6GB RAM with a 50% setting, but it's ment to be 2GB.Conan hat geschrieben:Could it also have something to do with Virtual memory ?
...
This would be a bug in BOINC - and I guess someone would already have found it and tracked it down - but otoh. some bugs in BOINC are quite sticky :-/
I rather think that BOINC respects the estimated maximum for a workunit (rsc_memory_bound) and it stops the WU when this maximum could bring BOINC over the user limits when continuing. That doesn't mean that it will violate the RAM limit from the user settings, it just means that it has the potential to violate it.
Afterall the WU might try to allocate RAM up to rsc_memory_bound immediately when it would be allowed to continue (worst case).
vi BOINC/checkin_notes
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Waiting for memory
Although things seem to work for you now, could yo please provide a link to that WU for me?Jax hat geschrieben:I know from the from news on the front page that some of the work units may require large amount of RAM. But I have a work unit (Task 1305845) that is sitting with "Waiting for memory" and not running even though there 12gb installed on the machine with 8.5gb free. I have 2 other cmsearch units running and combined they are using just under 2gb or memory. Any idea why this unit would not be running, there are no other free tasks available so it is just leaving an available core idle, I can't image it could possibly need more than that amount of memory.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


-
Ananas
- WU-Schieber

- Beiträge: 1184
- Registriert: 27.04.2008 18:37
- Wohnort: Nordlichter Köln
Re: Waiting for memory
He did that (nearly) ... http://www.rnaworld.de/rnaworld/result. ... id=1305845Michael H.W. Weber hat geschrieben:Although things seem to work for you now, could yo please provide a link to that WU for me?Jax hat geschrieben:... (Task 1305845) ...
Michael.
vi BOINC/checkin_notes
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
:1,$s/bug/feature/g
:wq!
Erzaehlen sich Biologen eigentlich Klein-RNA-Witze?
-
Michael H.W. Weber
- Vereinsvorstand

- Beiträge: 23174
- Registriert: 07.01.2002 01:00
- Wohnort: Marpurk
Re: Waiting for memory
Ah, the opossum. That one is tough. 
Michael.
Michael.
Fördern, kooperieren und konstruieren statt fordern, konkurrieren und konsumieren.


